"We will not remove the old playground in 2017," Indy Parks director Linda Broadfoot told a City-County Council committee, according to Indy Midtown Magazine. "There's no capital reason to do it."
That playground at the northwest corner of Tarkington Park, across 40th Street from the MLK Center, is still standing. On Oct. 15, 2026, the Indianapolis Metropolitan Development Commission approved the final plan to replace it, WFYI reported. Over the last ten years the park has been rebuilt in phases from south to north. The first phase served young children and summer afternoons. The phases now finishing serve older kids, teenagers, and anyone who wants a real court. The northwest playground is the last major piece of that plan. The other piece the park has never settled, the café, is empty again.
The south end was the first bet
The current Tarkington Park began with a roughly $5 million construction project in 2015. It produced the southern playground, the splash pad, a basketball court, and the café building, according to WFYI. Indy Midtown Magazine reported the total as $5.3 million when it covered the work. Partners including the Indianapolis Parks Foundation and Midtown Indianapolis Inc. helped bring that investment in. Broadfoot called the park "a new model for us."
That first phase put the splash pad and the playground for little kids at the south end. For years the north end held the old playground and open ground. The plan always meant to get to it, and it took about a decade to arrive.
Where each part of the park stands this fall
The table below covers the park at 45 W. 40th St., open dawn to dusk, based on the most recent city and news updates through mid-October 2026.
Area | What's there | Status this fall |
|---|---|---|
South end | Playground, splash pad, performance shelter | Splash pads are closed citywide for the season |
Basketball courts | Two renovated courts | Unveiled Sept. 16, 2026 |
North end | Multi-use field, walking path, tennis and pickleball courts | Finished in 2026. Courts closed for contractor repairs and field fenced as of Indy Parks' September update |
Northwest corner, 40th and Illinois | Playground installed about 20 years ago | Replacement approved Oct. 15. Permits expected mid-November |
Café building | Former Tea's Me Community Cafe, public restrooms | Café closed Aug. 1, 2026 |
The newest finished piece is the pair of basketball courts. The Pacers Foundation and Purdue University unveiled them on Sept. 16, 2026, working with Indy Parks and The Parks Alliance of Indianapolis, the Indianapolis Recorder reported. One court is Indiana Fever-branded, in red and blue, with Tamika Catchings' signature and a Fire Orange 3-point line. The orange arc is part of a WNBA initiative honoring girls and women on park courts around the country. The other court is in Purdue gold and black and carries the signature of Fever head coach Stephanie White, who won a 1999 national championship with the Boilermakers. The courts were built under the Pacers Foundation's "State of Play" initiative. The Indiana State Police Alliance also committed $250,000 over five years toward community courts across the state.
"This is a special place because it gives people in the neighborhood a place to come together, play and create memories," Catchings said at the unveiling, according to the Recorder.
The north end was built for older kids, on purpose
The roughly $3 million north-end project broke ground on Feb. 25, 2025, the Indianapolis Recorder reported. It added a multi-use field, a walking path, and new tennis and pickleball courts, according to Mirror Indy. The field is named the Richard "Coach Nell" Hamilton Field, after the coach of the Indy Steelers Youth Football program, which has practiced on that ground since 2005.
Indy Parks' project roundup says the field, path, and courts were completed earlier in 2026. In its September update, the Tarkington Park page said the new courts were temporarily closed so the contractor could repair lines and cracks. The field was still closed while its grass grew in, and the fence was expected to come down in early September. As late as Sept. 22, the Recorder described the Hamilton field as "soon-to-open." Before you bring a pickleball paddle, check that page or call the park at 317.327.4553.
The new playground follows the same idea. "The focus of the playground is to provide a safe and active space for older children, those teens and tweens, if you will," project manager Kyle Koger told WFYI. The plan includes equipment designed for that age group, a paved walkway, and an outdoor shelter.
When the work is done, the park will be split roughly by age. Young children have the south end with its splash pad and playground. Older kids and adults have the north end with the courts, the field, and the new playground.
Twelve trees became three
The first version of the playground plan would have removed 12 trees. Those trees are mature, but they did not meet the criteria the city uses for "heritage trees." After residents raised concerns, the city revised the design.
"We reevaluated the grading, kind of tightened up some of the slopes and contours, and were able to mitigate removal of those trees from 12 – originally proposed – down to three trees needing removal," Koger told WFYI.
Neighbors have shaped this park before. When the first phase was finishing, an outreach effort drew nearly 500 survey responses and 164 program ideas. More than 50 people came to a workshop at Mount Zion Baptist Church to suggest where those activities should go and at what times. The tree change is the most recent example of that input changing a plan.
The money behind the corner
The playground's $1 million comes from a $22.5 million Lilly Endowment grant that Butler University received in 2024. According to Butler's announcement, the grant's neighborhood plans also include:
- A 42,000-square-foot wellness center at the MLK Center for youth and sports programs, which was still a plan as of the announcement
- Restoration of Holcomb Gardens with native plants, along with campus landscaping done with the Indiana Native Plant Society
- A Safety and Transit Hub on campus
- Neighborhood infrastructure work coordinated with Midtown Indy Inc.
Some of that work is already done or under construction. Butler says the last of the 13 restored beds at Holcomb Gardens was finished in 2025. The Safety and Transit Hub broke ground in April 2026. It is planned as a seven-story building with a 664-space garage, due for completion in July 2027. The playground at 40th and Illinois is the grant's most visible project on the park side of the neighborhood. It sits directly across the street from the building where the wellness center is planned.
The café the park keeps having to refill
The café is the one part of the plan that hasn't stayed filled. When the first phase opened, Indy Parks said full café service would not start until 2018. The restrooms opened right away, and the city talked about bringing food trucks in to use the space in the meantime. In 2021, WRTV reported that Tamika Catchings was opening Tea's Me Community Cafe in the building as her second Indianapolis location.
Five years later, the café closed on Aug. 1, 2026. Mirror Indy reported that the company is not shutting down and will focus on its IU Indianapolis location. The Indy Parks page still lists the building as Tea's Me Community Café with public restrooms.
Catchings' signature is now on the new Fever court a short walk from the closed café. The courts, field, path, and playground each have funding and a schedule in the city's and Butler's published plans. The café space has neither.
What's next, in order
- Now through winter. Splash pads are closed for the season. Across the street, the MLK Center at 40 W. 40th St. describes Sassy Seniors beginner line dancing, open to all ages, as Fridays at 12:45 p.m. Its calendar listing shows Oct. 30 at 2 p.m., so check the time before you go.
- Mid-November. The city expects to receive permits for the northwest playground, and construction begins after that. Plan on fencing at the 40th and Illinois corner.
- May 2027. The new playground is scheduled to open.
- July 2027. Butler's Safety and Transit Hub is scheduled for completion.
By next summer, if the schedule holds, the corner Indy Parks chose to leave alone in 2017 will have a new playground, a shelter, and a paved path. The café building has no published timeline of its own.
If you'd like to talk about how projects like the Tarkington Park playground and Butler's Lilly-funded neighborhood work affect your corner of Butler-Tarkington, the team at Meridian x Main follows these plans closely and is glad to walk through them with you. Schedule a consultation whenever you're ready.