Meridian x Main Realty Partners
A warmly lit neighborhood restaurant table beside a large window overlooking autumn trees and an older brick building.

46th And College's Landmark Building Is Between Restaurants Again

A year ago this week, the curved former Kroger at 46th Street and College Avenue was full of people sampling Thanksgiving dinner tacos. Social Cantina had its soft opening there on Nov. 7, 2025, and opened officially on Nov. 10. The Current reported that the restaurant was filled with people trying the menu, including that month's Taco of the Month.

"As we looked for our next location in Indiana, opening in Broad Ripple-Meridian Kessler became the perfect fit," Chris Martin, president of Finney Hospitality Group, said in a statement the Current printed at the time.

Now the building is empty again. On Nov. 2, the Indianapolis Business Journal reported that Social Cantina had closed its Meridian-Kessler location as the chain scales back. That came almost exactly one year after opening day.

The Art Moderne building is the corner's best-known face, and since 2018 it has also been the corner's most frequent turnover. The plainer building next door at 4601 N. College Ave. has been the steady table, and that is where the corner's newest restaurant just opened.

A grocery store built with curves

The building at 4573 N. College Ave. opened in 1932 as a Kroger. It was designed by the Indianapolis firm Pierre & Wright, which also drew the Indiana State Library and Historical Bureau and Bush Stadium. As the IBJ described it in 2025, the building is all "dramatic curves and horizontal lines" on 4,500 square feet.

Its last grocery tenant was a Double 8, which closed in 2015, and the building then sat vacant for about three years. Gershman Partners, which owns the property, renovated it for a restaurant. Next Door American Eatery, a concept co-founded by Kimbal Musk, opened there in 2018.

That renovation turned an old supermarket into a restaurant space, and every tenant since has been a restaurant.

Two addresses, two very different track records

Here is how the two buildings have been occupied since 2018.

Address Tenant Open Closed
4573 N. College Next Door American Eatery, later ND StreetBar 2018 2022
4573 N. College Gallery Pastry Shop 2023 January 2025
4573 N. College Social Cantina Nov. 10, 2025 Reported closed Nov. 2, 2026
4601 N. College Root & Bone January 2020 June 7, 2026
4601 N. College Bocado Brunch & Te'Kila Early November 2026 Open

Each stay at 4573 has been shorter than the one before it. Next Door lasted about four years, and it rebranded as ND StreetBar before it closed in 2022. When the IBJ covered the closing in 2022, the landlord said ND StreetBar had pointed to workforce challenges and supply-chain problems. Gallery Pastry Shop moved in in 2023 and served for the last time on Jan. 12, 2025, according to the IBJ. Social Cantina lasted about a year.

Next door, one restaurant held the space for more than six years.

The steadier seat was next door

Root & Bone opened at 4601 N. College Ave. in January 2020. In its first-week coverage, Indianapolis Monthly described it as a Southern-food restaurant from chefs Janine Booth and Jeffrey McInnis. It stayed open longer than any restaurant has lasted in the landmark next door.

On April 27, 2026, the restaurant announced that its last day of service would be June 7. IndyStar reported that it gave no reason for closing after six years.

The landmark sat empty for roughly ten months between Gallery Pastry and Social Cantina. The Root & Bone space was empty about five months before its next tenant opened.

Mexican food stayed on the corner, one door north

Social Cantina came to 46th and College with a Mexican-inspired menu of tacos, burritos and bowls. Within days of the IBJ's closure report, a new Mexican-leaning restaurant was open in the building next door.

Bocado Brunch & Te'Kila is restaurateur Hugo Zavala's second location, following the original in Noblesville. The IBJ reported that the restaurant "won't follow conventional mealtime boundaries." Indianapolis Monthly's The Feed marked the grand opening in its Nov. 6 edition. It described the menu as "traditional Mexican flavors with a modern American twist," served with handcrafted cocktails.

The posted menu runs from brunch dishes like omelets, burritos and chilaquiles into dinner entrees. The restaurant's homepage bills it as a brunch-and-dinner spot built around tequila cocktails. Root & Bone was an upscale Southern-inspired restaurant known for its fried chicken. Bocado opens in the morning, so the corner now has a weekday breakfast spot on College. Hours at a new restaurant often shift in the first few weeks, so check Bocado's own site before you walk over.

A few blocks north, the corners with the holiday lights

Head up College or over to Pennsylvania and the next round of activity is clustered at 49th Street.

Slapfish is coming to 115 E. 49th St., near 49th and Pennsylvania. Indianapolis Monthly reported that signage outside advertised a Nov. 14 opening. The seafood chain started in California, but the IBJ reported in October that it is now almost entirely Indiana restaurants run by Mark and Lauren Weghorst. The only exception is a Los Angeles International Airport location run by an airport concessions operator.

That same 49th and Pennsylvania intersection is where the Meridian-Kessler Neighborhood Association flips the switch on its holiday lights. MK Shines! is set for Sunday, Nov. 29, from 4 to 6 p.m., kicking off the lighting of four business intersections. At last year's event, the lit corners were 49th and Penn, 49th and College, 52nd and College and 54th and College, and the switch-flip came with holiday music, hot chocolate and drinks from Upland and Shake-Up. The association's 2022 recap describes the same lights at 49th and Penn and along College, so the tradition dates back to at least 2022.

46th and College was not on last year's list. For holiday dinners this season, the corner's draw will be the restaurant at 4601.

The corner's calendar from here

  1. Now: Bocado Brunch & Te'Kila is serving at 4601 N. College Ave., brunch through dinner.
  2. Nov. 14: The date advertised on Slapfish's signage at 115 E. 49th St.
  3. Nov. 29, 4 to 6 p.m.: MK Shines! at 49th and Pennsylvania.
  4. Next: 4573 N. College Ave., the 1932 Pierre & Wright building, waits for its next restaurant tenant.

The Art Moderne building has outlived a Kroger, a Double 8 and every restaurant that has moved in since 2018, and its curves and horizontal lines still mark the corner of 46th and College.

At Meridian x Main, we keep track of corners like 46th and College because they shape how a block feels day to day, from where you grab breakfast to where you meet neighbors on a cold Sunday in late November. If you're curious how the restaurants and storefronts on College Avenue fit into your own plans in Meridian-Kessler, we'd be glad to walk through it with you. Schedule A Consultation whenever you're ready.

Work With Us

Our approach combines market expertise, strategic guidance, and genuine care to help you confidently buy or sell while strengthening your long-term investment potential. Connect with our team to begin your journey toward the perfect property.

Follow Us on Instagram